Concrete vs Brick vs Stone: Which Paver Works Best for Your Yard in St. Louis

St. Louis summers are all about backyard barbecues, but a cracked or uneven patio can quickly spoil the fun. If you’re thinking about upgrading your outdoor space, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is choosing the right paver material. The three most popular options—concrete, brick, and natural stone—each offer different strengths, styles, and price points. In this guide, we’ll compare these materials head-to-head to help you decide what works best for your yard in St. Louis. You’ll learn how each holds up in Midwest weather, how much maintenance they need, and which one adds the most long-term value.

Quick Summary – Choosing the Right Paver in St. Louis

• Concrete pavers are budget-friendly and versatile, great for patios and walkways, but may crack in freeze-thaw conditions.

• Brick pavers offer a classic aesthetic and strong resale appeal, though they cost more and may shift over time.

• Natural stone pavers deliver premium beauty and durability but require a higher investment and professional installation.

• Local climate and soil (especially in St. Louis) impact paver performance—freeze-thaw cycles, drainage, and slope matter.

• Factor in your budget, space use, long-term goals, and whether you’ll DIY or hire a pro.

Quick Comparison Table – Concrete vs Brick vs Stone

Before we dive deeper into individual pros and cons, here’s a quick at-a-glance comparison of concrete, brick, and stone across the most important categories for St. Louis yards:

This comparison lays the groundwork for deeper dives into each material’s strengths and weaknesses in the sections that follow.

Concrete Pavers – Affordable & Versatile

What Are Concrete Pavers Made Of?

Concrete pavers are manufactured from a mixture of cement, sand, gravel, and pigments. They’re formed in molds under high pressure, making them dense and durable. There are three main types to consider:

• Interlocking Pavers – Most common in residential use; uniform shapes make installation faster.

• Poured Slabs – Large concrete slabs poured in place; ideal for sleek, modern patios.

• Stamped Concrete – Mimics the look of brick or stone but is actually a single poured slab stamped with patterns.

Each option offers a different aesthetic and installation approach, which makes concrete one of the most versatile paver materials for homeowners.

Pros and Cons of Concrete Pavers

Concrete pavers are widely popular due to their affordability and flexibility in design. However, they come with trade-offs.

Pros:

• Cost-effective – Among the most budget-friendly options.

• Customizable – Available in many colors, textures, and shapes.

• Easy installation – Interlocking systems simplify DIY projects.

Cons:

• Prone to cracking – Especially without proper sub-base preparation.

• Surface fading – UV exposure can wear down pigmentation over time.

• Less natural-looking – May not achieve the organic appeal of brick or stone.

Despite these limitations, proper sealing and maintenance can significantly extend the life and look of concrete pavers.

Are Concrete Pavers Good for St. Louis Winters?

Yes — with the right prep. St. Louis winters bring freeze-thaw cycles that can wreak havoc on poorly installed concrete. Here’s what matters:

• Freeze-thaw resilience: Use a compacted sub-base and proper drainage to prevent heaving.

• Sealing: Apply a high-quality sealer to reduce water infiltration and surface spalling.

• Control joints: These help absorb thermal expansion and reduce cracking risk.

• Clay-heavy soil: In many St. Louis neighborhoods, expansive clay soil causes seasonal ground shifts using a thicker sub-base and geotextile fabric can help reduce movement beneath your pavers.

Homeowners in areas like Chesterfield or Ballwin, where clay soil is common, should take extra care in how concrete pavers are installed. For best results, consult a local paver installation expert who understands regional soil dynamics.

What About Permeable Concrete Pavers?

Permeable concrete pavers offer added benefits in areas prone to water pooling. These allow water to drain through the joints into the sub-base, reducing runoff and erosion. They’re especially useful in St. Louis backyards where heavy rain or poor drainage is common and can even help meet local stormwater management requirements.

Brick Pavers – Classic Look, Mid-Range Price

What Are Brick Pavers Made Of?

Brick pavers are made from clay that’s kiln-fired at high temperatures to create dense, durable units. Unlike structural bricks used for building walls, pavers are specifically engineered for ground applications. They come in uniform sizes and are often more porous, allowing for better drainage when installed correctly.

Two main installation types exist:

• Dry-laid (sand base): Bricks are set over a compacted gravel and sand layer. Easier to repair.

• Mortared (wet-laid): Bricks are laid over concrete and sealed with mortar. More permanent, but prone to cracking if not done properly.

Pros and Cons of Brick Pavers

Brick remains a favorite among homeowners who value tradition and timeless curb appeal.

Pros:

• Classic aesthetic – Warm red or earth tones add charm and historic character.

• Durability – Withstands decades of use with proper installation.

• Eco-friendly – Made from natural clay, often recyclable.

• Resale boost – Especially appealing in older or historic neighborhoods in St. Louis.

Cons:

• Higher cost – Typically more expensive than concrete.

• Limited color options – Mostly red, brown, or tan shades.

• Can shift over time – Particularly with freeze-thaw cycles or poor sub-base prep.

Because of their timeless appeal, brick pavers are especially popular in Central West End and other heritage-style areas across St. Louis.

How Do Brick Pavers Hold Up in Missouri Weather?

Missouri’s variable climate — with humid summers and cold, icy winters — can test the integrity of brick pavers over time.

• Freeze-thaw resistance: Brick is naturally porous, so moisture can get in and expand when frozen. Using a sand base with good drainage helps reduce cracking and shifting.

• Mortar issues: Mortared brick patios are more susceptible to cracking due to thermal expansion. In contrast, dry-laid bricks offer more flexibility.

• Shifting and settling: A thick, compacted gravel base with edge restraints reduces movement.

When installed correctly with a flexible sand base, brick pavers can last decades, even in neighborhoods like Kirkwood or University City where mature trees and older soils pose added challenges.

Natural Stone Pavers – Premium Look, Premium Price

What Types of Stone Are Common in St. Louis Yards?

Natural stone pavers offer unmatched elegance and durability, making them a favorite for luxury landscaping across St. Louis. Common options include:

• Bluestone: A dense, blue-grey sandstone popular for its non-slip texture and rich color variation. Often used in upscale patios and walkways.

• Flagstone: A broad category of sedimentary stones, including slate and sandstone, known for irregular shapes and earthy tones.

• Limestone: Soft-toned and widely available in Missouri, limestone provides a smooth finish and excellent durability, often seen in formal garden paths or pool surrounds.

Many of these materials can be sourced through local suppliers in the greater St. Louis area, which helps reduce transportation costs and supports regional businesses.

Pros and Cons of Stone Pavers

Natural stone adds character and a premium finish that manufactured options struggle to replicate.

Pros:

• Unmatched beauty – Each piece is unique in color and texture.

• High-end curb appeal – Boosts resale value in affluent neighborhoods.

• Durability – With proper installation, stone can last 50+ years.

• Natural drainage – Many types are naturally permeable.

Cons:

• Cost – Most expensive paver option, with prices ranging $15–$25+ per sq ft.

• Weight – Heavy materials require solid sub-base and expert handling.

• Labor-intensive – Installation is complex and best left to professionals.

Stone pavers are ideal for homeowners in areas like Town and Country or Chesterfield who want to make a long-term investment in their outdoor space.

Are Natural Stone Pavers Worth It in a Midwest Climate?

Midwest climates like St. Louis demand careful planning for stone installations:

• Drainage matters: Poor drainage can lead to frost heave or slippery ice patches in winter.

• Sealing is key: While some stones are naturally water-resistant, sealing improves stain resistance and reduces moisture penetration.

• Slope and grading: Ensure proper slope away from structures to prevent water pooling, especially in clay-heavy areas prone to expansion.

For high-traffic patios or sloped yards, combining natural stone with proper base prep — including geotextile fabric and compacted sub-base layers — ensures lasting performance in St. Louis weather.

Key Decision Factors for St. Louis Homeowners

What’s Your Budget Per Square Foot?

Budget often plays the biggest role when choosing between concrete, brick, and natural stone. Here’s a breakdown of typical cost ranges in the St. Louis area:

• Concrete Pavers: $6–$10 per sq ft

• Brick Pavers: $10–$14 per sq ft

• Natural Stone Pavers: $15–$25+ per sq ft

These figures vary depending on supplier, installation complexity, and whether drainage or grading is involved. According to estimates from HomeAdvisor, Angi, and local contractors, natural stone is clearly the premium choice. But with higher upfront cost often comes longer lifespan and stronger resale potential.

How Will You Use the Space?

Your intended use of the space should drive material selection:

• Driveways: Concrete is often best due to its compressive strength and affordability. Stone works too, but needs reinforced sub-base layers.

• Patios: Brick and stone both shine here. Brick offers traditional charm, while stone adds elegance for entertaining spaces.

• Pool Decks: Slip resistance matters most. Textured concrete or flagstone with natural grip is ideal.

• Walkways: Brick and stone add visual appeal and help create focal points along garden paths.

When in doubt, consider starting with a paver design consultation to map out which materials work best for each area.

Do You Plan to DIY or Hire a Pro?

Skill level and installation complexity differ significantly between materials:

• Concrete: Easier for confident DIYers if using precast interlocking types. Poured slabs or stamped designs are better left to pros.

• Brick: Manageable for DIY with proper base prep and sand setting. Mortared installations require more expertise.

• Natural Stone: Typically requires professional installation due to weight, irregular sizing, and drainage planning.

Also note: permits may be required if you’re installing driveway pavers or altering grading. For more details, see our guide on Retaining Wall Permits in St. Louis.

Long-Term Considerations Most Homeowners Overlook

Resale Value & Curb Appeal

When it comes to real estate in St. Louis, first impressions matter. A well-installed paver patio or walkway can significantly boost curb appeal, especially if using high-end materials like natural stone or carefully laid brick.

• Brick pavers tend to attract buyers looking for classic style.

• Natural stone enhances premium listings, especially in upscale neighborhoods like Chesterfield or Ladue.

• Concrete, while cost-effective, may require added design elements (like stamping or staining) to match the appeal of other options.

A thoughtfully chosen paver material can add thousands to resale value, especially if paired with other upgrades like retaining walls or outdoor kitchens.

Maintenance & Repairs

Each material type carries its own maintenance profile:

• Concrete may crack due to freeze-thaw cycles. Sealing can extend its life, but it may still require patching or resurfacing over time.

• Brick can shift or settle unevenly, especially on sand bases. Occasional re-levelling or joint sanding may be needed.

• Stone is highly durable but should be sealed to prevent moisture damage and algae growth.

St. Louis homeowners should also consider weed growth between joints, particularly in moist or shady areas. Using weed barrier fabric and proper joint filling (polymeric sand, for example) helps reduce this risk.

Lifespan & Warranty

Expected lifespan varies by material and installation quality:

• Concrete pavers: 20–30 years

• Brick pavers: 30–40 years

• Natural stone pavers: 50+ years with proper drainage and maintenance

Contractors in St. Louis typically offer 1–5 year warranties depending on the material and service scope. Be sure to ask about coverage for shifting, cracking, and drainage issues when comparing quotes for paver installation services in St. Louis.

FAQs – Real Homeowner Questions Answered

St. Louis homeowners often ask these practical questions when deciding between concrete, brick, and stone for their landscape projects. Here’s what to consider based on real-world experience and local regulations

Do I need a permit to install a new paver patio in St. Louis?

Yes. Most municipalities in St. Louis County require permits for patio installations especially when altering drainage, grading, or structural elements. If you’re planning to pour a base or connect the patio to a retaining wall, it’s essential to check with your local building office. For more on this, see our St. Louis retaining wall permit guide.

Can I mix paver types in the same yard?

Yes, but it requires planning. Combining brick, stone, and concrete pavers can look stunning if done intentionally. Use clear transitions, proper sub-base preparation, and keep similar thicknesses to avoid tripping hazards or uneven settling. Transitions between materials also affect water flow and freeze resistance.

What’s the best paver if my backyard gets muddy or soggy?

Choose permeable options. Natural stone with a drainage base or permeable concrete pavers are ideal. These allow water to filter through the joints and reduce pooling. Also consider adding a gravel sub-base and landscape fabric to manage runoff more effectively.

How do I prevent weeds between pavers in St. Louis?

Use polymeric sand and proper joint sealing. Especially in humid or shaded areas, weeds can take root between pavers. A combination of weed barrier fabric, compacted base layers, and polymeric sand between joints helps prevent growth.

Is DIY installation worth it, or should I hire a pro?

Depends on your scope and skill level. Small pathways or patios may be manageable with research and the right tools. But if you’re building a driveway, multi-material design, or anything with slope/drainage issues, professional help will ensure long-term stability.

Choose This Paver Type If You Want…	Best Option
Affordable, easy-to-install patios or walkways	Concrete Pavers
A timeless, traditional look that boosts resale appeal	Brick Pavers
Premium aesthetics with maximum durability and value	Natural Stone
Better drainage and minimal water pooling	Permeable Concrete or Natural Stone
Low-maintenance options for busy homeowners	Concrete or Stone
A patio that matches historic or colonial home styles	Brick Pavers
A long-lasting, high-end finish for a luxury backyard	Natural Stone

Paver Comparison Snapshot for St. Louis Homes

• Concrete is the most affordable and flexible but may crack or fade over time if not sealed.
• Brick offers a timeless look and good resale value, but costs more and can shift with soil movement.
  Natural stone delivers premium curb appeal and durability, though it requires expert installation and a higher upfront investment.
• Choose concrete for functional spaces like driveways or low-cost patios.
  opt for brick if you want a classic, mid-range solution with charm.
  Go with stone when aesthetics and longevity matter most—especially on slopes or high-visibility areas.

Always factor in your budget, soil type, usage plans, and weather resilience before making a final decision.

What Should You Do Next?

If you’re still unsure which paver material works best for your project, don’t guess. Factors like soil compaction, frost heave, and property slope all impact how well each option performs. You also want to weigh installation complexity, curb appeal, and long-term maintenance. Need help deciding? Retaining Wall & Paving Solutions offers expert guidance and professional paver installation across St. Louis. Whether you’re planning a driveway, pool deck, or backyard patio, our team can walk you through the materials, design, and local permitting process—so your new hardscape stands the test of time.